Freshly baked bagels on a wooden counter
Baked Fresh Daily · Brooklyn, NY

BOIL.
BAKE.
REPEAT.

Every bagel at Bagel Supreme follows the same time-honored process — boiled, then baked to golden perfection. No shortcuts. Just flavor.

See the Menu Call Us
Scroll
Interior of Bagel Supreme bakery with bagels on display

100%

Handcrafted Daily

Our Story

Not all bagels
are created equal.

At Bagel Supreme, we don't cut corners. Every batch starts with the same three steps that have defined great bagels for over a century: boil, bake, serve. The boil gives the crust its signature chew. The bake locks in the flavor. And serving them fresh? That's the part you'll never forget.

Located on 5th Avenue in Brooklyn, we've been serving our neighborhood one bagel at a time. No industrial ovens. No frozen dough. Just real ingredients, real technique, and real flavor.

Boil
Perfect crust
Bake
Golden finish
Serve
Fresh & hot
What People Say

Brooklyn's got
opinions. Ours win.

"I've tried bagel shops all over the city and nothing comes close. The texture, the flavor — it's like they actually care about what they're making. My family drives from Staten Island just for these."

M

Maria G.

Regular since 2019

"The smoked salmon bagel changed my life. I'm not being dramatic. I come here every Saturday morning and it's the highlight of my week. The staff remembers my order."

J

James T.

Weekly regular

"As someone who grew up in NYC, I'm picky about my bagels. Bagel Supreme is the real deal — dense interior, chewy crust, and they actually taste like they were made with intention."

S

Sarah L.

Brooklyn local

Find Us

Come say hi.

We're right here on 5th Avenue. Walk in, smell the fresh bagels, and make your pick.

Address

9401 5th Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11209

Hours

Monday – Friday: 6:00 AM – 7:00 PM

Saturday: 7:00 AM – 6:00 PM

Sunday: 7:00 AM – 5:00 PM

Get Directions

Fresh bagels
don't wait.

Stop by Bagel Supreme on 5th Avenue and taste the difference that fresh dough and traditional technique makes.

Call (718) 745-1108 Find Us
Is this your business? Claim your website
Your own domain includedLive in minutes, edit anytime
Claim my website